← Back to The Late Edition
How to Play 3 min read

A Hunch Does Not Convict: How the Case Board Works

Fixed solutions, proof and heat — Chalkline’s signature rule, explained

D
Dave

Every game on this platform has one rule that makes it feel like itself. In Chalkline it is the Case Board. The problem with most mysteries run by a storyteller — human or AI — is that the answer can drift: if you guess well enough, the culprit quietly becomes whoever you guessed. Chalkline does not allow that.

The solution is fixed

When a case opens, the AI DM records four things on the server: the culprit, the motive, the means and the opportunity. You never see them. The DM can never change them. Every clue it hands out from then on has to be consistent with that answer.

The board

A panel above the story shows the Case Board, which your whole table can read. It holds:

Heat

Dorrance has a rule for this, the Three Visits: a word, then a lesson, then the harbour. Always in that order. Heat is how you know which visit is next.

The accusation

When you think you know, you accuse. The server checks your accusation against the hidden solution — and against the proof on the board. To make it stick you need the right culprit, proof that it was them, and proof of at least two of the other three: why, how, and how they had the chance. Name the right person on a hunch and you have told everyone what you know without being able to do anything about it.

Habits of investigators who close cases

The easiest way to learn the board is to open The Halloran Ledger.