← Back to The Late Edition
How to Play 3 min read

The Rules of Dorrance, and the Reasons for Them

The Three Visits, proof that survives, lead and what it costs, the harbour, owing the Machine and your licence — what each rule does, and why

D
Dave

Chalkline runs on the d20 core of the free fifth-edition rules, with no magic of any kind, and a short list of rules that belong only to a bought city in 1948. Each is simple. Each is there because Dorrance would not feel like Dorrance without it.

The Three Visits

How the city deals with a nuisance: a word, then a lesson, then the harbour, always in that order. At Heat 4 the investigators get the word, clearly, from a named person. At Heat 7 they get the lesson — an ambush meant to leave them beaten, not dead, unless someone draws a gun. At Heat 10, the harbour.

Why: it turns menace into a clock you can read. Pushing hard is sometimes right; this rule tells you what it costs before you pay.

Proof That Survives

A clue counts as proof only while it is secured. Hand it to the police or the district attorney and roll a die each day: on a 1 or 2 it is gone. It is secured by a photostat left with someone else, a sworn statement before a notary, a recording, a front page or a federal receipt. And a witness is proof only while alive, in town and willing.

Why: in a bought city, finding the evidence is half the job and keeping it in existence is the other half. This one rule makes Dorrance feel corrupt without the DM having to say so.

Lead and What It Costs

Gunfights are short, loud and remembered. A character brought down by a bullet or a blade is Bleeding Out. One who survives is Laid Up for weeks. Every shot is heard for a block.

Why: violence should be the last and worst option in a detective game, not the default. In Chalkline it is.

The Harbour

Fifty degrees and forty feet deep at the piers. In a coat or holding a gun, staying up is hard; each failure is exhaustion, and at three you go under. The tide brings everything back to Pier 31.

Why: the harbour is where Dorrance puts its problems, and it should be the most frightening place on the map.

Owing the Machine

Any investigator may ask the Machine for one thing an official could do, through a ward captain or Mr. Gault, and get it the same day. Then the crew owes — and the Machine calls the card in at the worst moment.

Why: everyone in Dorrance has taken a favour. This rule lets you take one too, and feel exactly what it costs.

The Licence and the Badge

At Heat 7 your licence is “under review” and honest officials are slow to help. At Heat 10 it is gone, and carrying a gun is a felony. It comes back by clearing the case that cost it, by a favour — or with the election.

Why: private investigators in 1948 worked at the city’s pleasure. Losing the licence is the noir equivalent of losing your sword.

These, and more — Six O’Clock Fog, A Night in the Fourteenth, Whose Ground, A Nickel for the Phone — are in the Lexicon. The Case Board itself has its own post: A Hunch Does Not Convict.