← Back to The Late Edition
How to Play 3 min read

Hard and Fair: Nobody Is Bulletproof, and Nobody Starts Again

The two promises at the heart of Chalkline, and the three rules that keep them

D
Dave

The AI Dungeon Master that runs Chalkline is told that Dorrance is fair and does not forgive. A pistol at ten feet, the harbour in October, the wrong car and a back room with no witnesses can each end an investigator. It is told never to soften a result or invent a lucky escape.

Hard-boiled stories are about people who take risks with their lives for the truth. If the risk is not real, neither is the story. In Chalkline, when you decide to go into the Anchor Light’s back room alone, you are deciding something.

Promise one: the city always warns you first

Trouble in Dorrance always shows itself to those who look: the same grey coupe two turnings running, a telephone that rings and says nothing, a friendly word from a policeman, a door that was locked and is not. If you see the sign and go on anyway, you take the full consequence. If you lay low, change your route, keep your copies safe — you live.

The city even has a rule for it, the Three Visits: a word, then a lesson, then the harbour. Always in that order. Heat on the Case Board tells you which visit is next.

Promise two: you never start again

The case does not die with the investigator. In Dorrance it never has.

Why it fits Dorrance

Dorrance in October 1948 is a city with a machine at City Hall, a family on the docks, an election in three weeks and forty-one dead from a cannery fire that nobody was ever charged for. Its investigators are not superheroes. They are tired people with licences that can be taken away, doing a dangerous job because somebody has to. A game set there must feel exactly that dangerous, and exactly that stubborn.

Keep your own copies. Watch for the grey coupe. And never accuse anybody you cannot prove.

Every rule here has an entry in the Lexicon.